
Parents are supposed to love all their children equally, but my siblings and I knew our parents had favorites. They always said they loved us the same, and they tried not to let their favoritism show, but still, we all knew…because we listened at the door on Mother’s Day as they criticized the cards we had made, and Mom always made fun of my card the least.
All my siblings (except one delusional older brother) agreed I was Mom’s favorite. How did we know? I guess we could tell by the little things, like how I was the only kid who got a vaccination against smallpox while the others received a shot for smallpox.
Despite this obvious favoritism, nobody seemed jealous because they all agreed I was probably Dad’s least favorite. How did we know? I guess it was the little things, like how he couldn’t remember my name.
As an adult, I realize I’m not my mom’s favorite anymore because I’ve been living far away for most of my adult life, and she sees her second-string children far more often. She once told me–not so much with words but more so with a look–that twenty visits from her boring children equaled one incredibly awesome visit from me.
Also, I probably fell out of favor when I wrote an unauthorized biography of my mom full of unflattering stories like how she would never let us eat treats, but she always had a Snickers in her purse. I shopped it to publishers, but they declined to offer me a deal because the book was too juicy for publication. Also because it was written on napkins.
Mom, I ask you to reconsider your current rankings of children by reminding you of the following:
I’m the one that talked the family out of putting you in an assisted living facility…back when you were forty and still in perfect health.
Remember when you ran that marathon? I probably shouldn’t be telling you this, but the whole family met secretly to discuss how to talk you out of trying so you wouldn’t embarrass yourself. On the question of whether we believed in you, everyone voted “nay” except for me, who instead voted “present”. Because I was your favorite, I was chosen as their representative to beg you to drop out, but instead I lied to you and said we were behind you 100 percent. I went back to the group and told them you were only planning to run the marathon as a joke and had promised to stop after ten steps and say, “How much further is it? Twenty-six miles! I thought a marathon was twenty-six meters.”
You’re welcome, Mom.
Most of the times I got in trouble growing up, it was actually me taking the blame for other siblings because I knew you would be discouraged by what terrible children they had become, and I decided to redistribute some of their shortcomings onto me, the perfect child.
You’re welcome, Mom.
Remember when we were at the grocery store when I was eleven, and I found the grocery store public address microphone and accused you of shoplifting over the loudspeaker? You didn’t laugh at the time, but I think the shame you felt that day taught you a lesson that has helped you avoid turning to a life of crime.
You’re welcome, Mom.
Remember when I was a teenager and you couldn’t find your glasses and you searched everywhere for two months? Who found your glasses in the couch? I did. And who put them back in the glasses case in your purse so you would think you were losing your mind when you found them in the very first place you had looked two months earlier? I never told you I put them there, so you never knew you owed me a thanks for finding them.
You’re welcome, Mom.
Remember when you would ask me if I had taken “a cookie” and I would answer no and felt I was being honest because I had taken “multiple cookies”? And sometimes you would ask if I had “hit” my brother, and I answered no and felt I wasn’t lying because I had “kicked” my brother. And remember when you asked if I had “sold” my younger brother, and I answered no because I “gave” him away and received no monetary compensation? These were all carefully orchestrated lessons in both semantics and in the importance of treating everything people say with suspicion and paranoia.
You’re welcome, Mom.
And to that delusional brother who thought he was mom’s favorite, you should know, mom used to wake me up after you went to sleep, and we would eat popcorn as we read your diary, and laughed.
ajg
May 6, 2011
I always thought I did my mom a favor by not developing schizophrenia. Seeing as how I live in her basement, that would have made her life a lot more difficult. Sure, I’m an arsonist, but it’s always kept her in newly built homes.
The Good Greatsby
May 6, 2011
Moms love to decorate. Every time you force her to move, she gets a chance to decorate again.
Renee Davies
May 6, 2011
That is so funny.
judithhb
May 6, 2011
We are all so kind to our Mothers – wonder if they appreciate us. 🙂
The Good Greatsby
May 6, 2011
Moms get so much attention, but when do we celebrate the people who make mom’s life difficult so she can be deserving of attention?
amblerangel
May 6, 2011
I know payback will be Hell every time I think about a certain pair of African spears broken in half at a secret party and then hidden between the matresses of Thin Lips’ bed- mom’s nickname. Good times good times.
The Good Greatsby
May 6, 2011
That sounds like some party.
officeoddities
May 6, 2011
If you were her favourite, your siblings must be monsters.
( Btw I love this post – so so good!)
The Good Greatsby
May 6, 2011
They were and still are terrible, terrible people…compared to me.
Your older brother
May 6, 2011
It’s a journal, not a diary… and now I know why all the pages have popcorn grease stains on them.
You’re so busted. Mom’s gonna hear about this.
The Good Greatsby
May 6, 2011
I know Mom called it a journal to your face, but she always called it a diary when you weren’t around. I’m not sure what she meant by that.
carldagostino
May 6, 2011
My mother has one of those huge wooden salad spoons welded to her hand . It never touched a leaf of lettuce but is familiar with every part of my body. She whacked it with me yesterday. So what.you might ask. I’ll tell you so what. I’m 62 and she’s 88.
The Good Greatsby
May 6, 2011
And I’m sure you had it coming because mother knows best.
Ahmnodt Heare
May 6, 2011
I am not my mother’s favorite child. It’s sad because I grew up as an only child. I’d bring kids over to play and when their parents came over to pick them up, my mom would try to convince them that I was their child.
The Good Greatsby
May 6, 2011
Sounds like you had a very Dangerfield-esque upbringing.
Renee Davies
May 6, 2011
Kids who make their parents laugh are definitely favorites. I can totally believe you were your mom’s favorite. I love this post. Moms are GREAT.
The Good Greatsby
May 6, 2011
Moms are the best. Without moms, none of us would be here.
limr
May 6, 2011
That response would be funnier to me if it didn’t trigger flashbacks of all the times I’ve read that in essays by students who weren’t kidding.
Lenore Diane
May 6, 2011
I don’t want to come right out and say you are predictable; however, the title alone caused me to laugh. As I laughed throughout, I couldn’t help but be glad you are – predictable. Entertaining, funny and probably my favorite blogger. Though don’t tell that to the other bloggers. I’ve said the same to them, too.
~Lenore
The Good Greatsby
May 6, 2011
I appreciate the great compliment, but I can’t promise I won’t tell the other bloggers. As a matter of fact, I’m very likely to mention it at every opportunity.
Meet the Buttrams
May 6, 2011
Seriously.
Our moms wouldn’t be moms if it weren’t for us, anyway.
The Good Greatsby
May 6, 2011
Without us kids our moms would just be regular people. It’s about time moms said thanks.
Amy
May 6, 2011
Coming from a fellow “favorite child” I can relate to this post. People don’t realize the pressure of being the favorite. Not every kid is strong enough to handle it.
The Good Greatsby
May 6, 2011
There was always so much pressure to smooth over the rough edges of the second-string children.
Jeane
May 6, 2011
You might just be my long lost sibling. My mom hated lessons in semantics! Truly think if teachers put it in that context students would get it in a snap. We could never pull off store announcer because by the time we had thought about it our mom had all ready forgotten us and was half way home…so what was the point really.
The Good Greatsby
May 6, 2011
My mom never appreciated my efforts to prepare her for a potential court deposition.
madtante
May 6, 2011
Nice piece. Trying how or how not to think of my mother right now…
The Good Greatsby
May 6, 2011
I don’t want you to change your opinion of your mother at all. I just want awesome kids to get the attention they deserve.
thelifeofjamie
May 6, 2011
I think I was my mom’s favorite…My sister was (and still is) clearly hands down without a shadow of a doubt my dad’s favorite. I’m okay with that- it means he goes to her house to do laundry.
The Good Greatsby
May 6, 2011
I was surprised when my siblings and I discussed the ranking of favorites as adults and we pretty much came to the same conclusions.
Todd Pack
May 6, 2011
Nicely done, Greatsby. I wasn’t Mom’s favorite, which is OK, except I was an only child.
educlaytion
May 6, 2011
Great line Todd.
As for you Greatsby, I’m beginning to get jealous. People think I write a lot? You are scary prolific and what’s worse you are consistently funny. Makes me sick. In a good way.
The Good Greatsby
May 6, 2011
If I weren’t so busy being “prolific” I’d have time to look up “prolific” in the dictionary.
The Good Greatsby
May 6, 2011
Did any other moms like you?
frigginloon
May 6, 2011
Sophie’s Choice had the best solution to weeding out mom’s favorite!
The Good Greatsby
May 6, 2011
I didn’t see Sophie’s Choice, but does it have anything to with the coffee Taster’s Choice?
jacquelincangro
May 6, 2011
When I was a kid, and I had made my third or fourth thumb-print ash tray for Mother’s Day, I had the same revelation. Maybe she should have been making me thumb-print ash trays all along as a way to thank me for being her kid. Very crafty, Mom.
The Good Greatsby
May 6, 2011
And how good of a mom could she really be if she smoked enough to need a new ash tray every year?
Gemma Sidney
May 6, 2011
I just knew you were a mama’s boy.
Was that you in French film “Tanguy”? The resemblance is striking.
The Good Greatsby
May 6, 2011
I haven’t seen the film, but I’m assuming this character was awesome.
pegoleg
May 6, 2011
Every week we’d watch “The Brady Bunch”, and every week I’d accuse my parents of not caring, because they NEVER sensed I was upset about an incoming pimple or rejection by the Big Man On Campus, and they NEVER came in my room with Dad’s arm around Mom, an expression of grave concern on their faces, to find out what was wrong.
Things kind of went down hill with us after that.
The Good Greatsby
May 6, 2011
But didn’t you find Mike and Carol gave you all the parenting you needed?
pegoleg
May 6, 2011
I don’t know – they seemed preoccupied so much of the time, what with Jan’s problems getting the curl on her payot just right, and Peter’s undiagnosed Middle Child Rage issues.
sunnywithachanceofarmageddon
May 6, 2011
This was hilarious. I mean, real gut busting stuff. My favorite part was when you said that you were your dad’s least favorite. How could you tell? Because he couldn’t remember your name. Yeah, that’s my dad, LOL.
The Good Greatsby
May 6, 2011
Maybe if he’d given me a more complicated name I’d understand him forgetting, but Paul is pretty easy to remember, especially because he required me to wear a name tag.
pearlsandprose
May 6, 2011
How you make me laugh. “Second-string children”!!
The Good Greatsby
May 6, 2011
I wish I could take credit for coining the term “second-string children”, but that was my mom.
bridgesburning
May 6, 2011
It’s tough for siblings to live in the shadow of a greater..or Greatsby..I know..all my siblings tell me so. Come Easter I would point out to the younger four that Mom and Dad did not have treats…so I made them put together a basket sharing their treats which I then presented to them with great fan fair..and their hearts were touched by MY thoughtfulness.
The Good Greatsby
May 7, 2011
Sounds like you and I have a lot in common. It can certainly be a burden to be the favorite.
Tori Nelson
May 6, 2011
You’re mom’s one lucky lady. No wonder you were the favorite! Did you ever gift her a robot that could not do dishes better than she could not do dishes?
The Good Greatsby
May 7, 2011
She really is a lucky lady, an extremely lucky lady.
Jess Witkins
May 7, 2011
Wow, we actually might have had the same dad. Mine still spells my name wrong on my birthday cake. This post was hilarious! I hope your mom actually laughs. I try to share funny stories about my childhood, and all my mom ever says is “You’re going to get us arrested!”
The Good Greatsby
May 7, 2011
If spelling the name correctly is a reflection of like, then neither of my parents like my wife either.
spilledinkguy
May 7, 2011
Hahaha…
I don’t think your siblings should feel slighted.
It’s not like shots for smallpox just grow on trees, you know.
🙂
The Good Greatsby
May 7, 2011
But if money was tight, why did my parents buy my siblings shots for smallpox when that shot was way more expensive than the vaccine against?
writerwoman61
May 7, 2011
I can’t remember my children’s names either, Paul…I’ve been known to call them by pet’s names at times…
My brother and I could never take just one cookie…it was always three at a time…but they were so good!
Wendy
The Good Greatsby
May 7, 2011
It’s a child’s responsibility to make himself so memorable that the parents never forget his name. Your children have to take a good look in the mirror and ask why mom doesn’t remember their names.
savesprinkles1234
May 7, 2011
My mother never thanked me for all of the exciting, highly educated people that she got to meet because of me. I’m pretty certain that both my junior high and high school principals both had doctorates and speaking with my many teachers, who always seemed to be eager to call her during the school day, probably also enriched her life. Ungrateful!
The Good Greatsby
May 7, 2011
I just helped you expand your social circle, Mom, but you only want to talk about the trouble I’m in.
berettaluvz26
May 7, 2011
I’m the middle kid, so I can’t be my mom’s favorite. That’s alright, though. I’m going to have 3 kids so the middle one can be my favorite. I have to make up for years of neglect.
The Good Greatsby
May 7, 2011
Make sure and shower that middle child with all the favoritism your parents neglected to give you.
flippingchannels
May 7, 2011
Of course this is just speculation right? We all know I’m your Mother’s real favorite!
The Good Greatsby
May 8, 2011
I worry about the results if she were allowed to pick favorites from outside her genetic children.
She's a Maineiac
May 7, 2011
I have five brothers and all of our names start with D. When my mom was steaming mad and forgot my name, she’d yell out a quick run-down of the list, so for years I was known as “Dave-Dan-Dale-Darrin-” She’d usually give up when the vein on her forehead exploded.
The Good Greatsby
May 8, 2011
There are certainly some advantages to being the last child in a large family. Mom and Dad have usually run out of energy by the time they get to you.
Kim
May 7, 2011
Oh yeah, we all have our favorites…it’s like a secret underground thing that is never supposed to be discussed… like Fight Club…
The Good Greatsby
May 8, 2011
I was surprised by how unbiased my siblings were in discussing my parents’ favorites. I thought everyone would claim they were the favorite, but we generally agreed on the rankings.
Kim
May 9, 2011
One of the perks of being an only child… winner by default!!!
nursemyra
May 7, 2011
My brother and I were adopted as babies and I always suspected of the two of us that he was mum’s favourite. When she woke up in hospital after undergoing an operation she was told she had a terminal cancer (she was actually still groggy from the procedure and had misheard but we didn’t know that at the time). She passed the news on to us at visiting time and I started to cry. She said “There, there darling, don’t cry. Everything will be all right, you know you were always my favourite…………………………. (major pause during which I looked at my brother with a momentary sense of my own importance)………. daughter.”
WTF?
The Good Greatsby
May 8, 2011
But at least you were the favorite daughter, right?
ladyjustine
May 7, 2011
Being favourite carries heavy responsibilities. I’m not the favourite. I look to the favourite to care for my mother and do all the things she should do, like call her, visit and so on. It’s great not being favourite. I vote for being second-string any day – much more liberating. Plus, it teaches you a lesson about life: life is harsh. If you learn that early in life, it stops you going on to become an over-achiever.
The Good Greatsby
May 8, 2011
I try and tell my second-string siblings how easy they have it, but they just don’t understand.
monicastangledweb
May 7, 2011
What did your mother do to deserve such a son as you? Her only consolation must be that one day one of your boys (perhaps your favorite?) will do to you what you did to your mom and he’ll be saying to you “You’re welcome.” But he’d be better off saying, “Quid pro quo.”
The Good Greatsby
May 8, 2011
If you’re trying to say my mom is very, very lucky, I absolutely agree.
Calhoun
May 7, 2011
My mom regularly confused my name and the dog’s name.
Mine is Calhoun.
My dog was a prissy, white bichon frise named Sugar.
I think my mom might hate me…
The Good Greatsby
May 8, 2011
But Calhoun and Sugar sound so much alike.
lifeintheboomerlane
May 8, 2011
I wasn’t the favorite, and I’m an only child.
The Good Greatsby
May 8, 2011
To paraphrase Rodney Dangerfield, you get no respect.
zmanowner
May 8, 2011
I was Mom’s favorite and at 39 I still am…the conversation almost always gravitate to…you can do anything i knew you would never let me down i am so proud of you……i was the baby and by far got the most attention……i wonder why that happens……great post though and so true…zman sends
The Good Greatsby
May 8, 2011
I’m sure you were absolutely deserving of your mom’s favoritism.
the master
May 10, 2011
I’m a full-time carer for my elderly mother. I tell you, it’s the toughest job in the world ignoring her when she winges about being bored and lonely in her room, or about needing the toilet, or about needing her pills. Luckily she finally shut about five days ago.