
When I look back at my life I realize all my happiest moments involved plans falling through.
When Mom flips through a photo album and talks about the big moments in life that brought her joy, a wedding, a family reunion, a child’s piano recital, I realize all of my happiest, most fulfilling moments have involved finding out I didn’t have to go to those things.
I wish I’d taken more pictures of those moments.
Is there anything more satisfying than getting all bundled up to spend three hours on the icy sideline of your kid’s soccer game, and on the way out the door getting a call that the game has been cancelled?
Put that moment in a bottle and open it on the day that same kid graduates from college and tell me which moment is more satisfying.
I’m not talking about simple laziness. Humans have evolved to find laziness existentially unsatisfying. I’m talking about the power of good intentions.
Remember when friend A said he was moving and friend B immediately offered to help, and you pretended your phone was ringing and stepped out to take a call? And remember how jealous you felt when friend A decided not to move and friend B got all the pat-on-the-back utility of feeling like he was a good person without having to do any work?
Want to know the secret to winning life? Surveys have shown planning a trip can immediately improve happiness. Surveys have also shown no difference in happiness post-trip compared to somebody who stayed home. The secret is to plan and not take lots of trips.
Nothing beats the thrill of looking commitment in the eye, coming oh so close, and then saying, ‘That’s enough for today.’
Occasionally you will have to actually take a trip or your brain will stop believing your fake plans, but the good news is that once you step on that plane your utility work is done. I love to travel to exotic cities and never leave the hotel.
Oh, I leave the hotel room, but usually stop at the Starbucks in the lobby. I’ve had Starbucks vanilla lattes in all of the world’s great cities. I’ve sipped Starbucks in Beijing, Hong Kong, Seoul, Sydney, Melbourne, Kuala Lumpur, Singapore, London, San Francisco, New York, Paris, and Amsterdam, all while perched in a window, watching people on foot and bikes and in cars rushing towards a commitment to move a friend’s couch.
When the Starbucks barista asks my name I always answer, ‘Good Intentions.’

Starbucks city mugs can be ordered online. You don’t actually have to go to those places.
We’re in the midst of a ‘making plans’ revolution. Social media and 24/7 connection mean it only takes one second to make a 10-hour commitment, or a few seconds to make commitments that will occupy the rest of your year. There’s no correlation between the speed of making plans, and the hours available to follow through with those plans.
It used to be a lot of work to commit. You had to write and mail a letter. Or gather kindling to build a fire to send smoke signals. The slow pace of communication left plenty of time to remember doing things is the worst.
But here’s the solution: Technology has also made it easier to cancel plans. If you know you have a ‘making plans’ addiction, Meetup is the ‘canceling plans’ answer.
Think ahead and manage the addiction.
Every Sunday I look through a long list of interesting Meetups, and commit to one for every night of the week. I get all the commitment out of my system before somebody asks me to come to a recital or help with a move.
And every day I get to cancel plans. Yes, I occasionally do go to a Meetup, it’s important to keep tricking the brain, but most days I click a little button to cancel after experiencing a last second severe case of ‘good intentions’.
susielindau
February 28, 2017
So that’s why I hate it when a trip it planned at the last minute! Deep down, I must have known that I wasted all kinds of endorphin potential by not thinking about it for weeks before I left.
The Good Greatsby
February 28, 2017
You’re definitely being cheated out of a lot of the benefit. I remember being a kid and sending away for things and everything was 6-8 weeks away. And as an adult I can buy anything instantly. The experience of waiting often outweighs the actual getting what we want.
susielindau
February 28, 2017
That is so true. I discussed that weird phenomena recently. Visualization of something may be a heck of a lot better than the actual experience. We should just sit in a dark room and fantasize!
The Good Greatsby
February 28, 2017
Visualization goes a long way. I’m going to start asking my mom to first try visualizing the family reunion before I give her a commitment.
susielindau
February 28, 2017
Good idea.
Jim Wheeler
February 28, 2017
You are right, Paul, there is a pleasurable explosion of endorphins whenever you make a change of course or decision. When the wife and I were on a travel tour some years ago, the tour bus would occasionally make a stop for shopping at some touristy place. The tour guide called it “retail therapy” for a reason, that little flash of pleasure at acquiring something new, never mind that it would likely just gather dust in a closet on on a shelf.
Last fall, I made an adjustment to our mutual fund investment accounts. It’s called asset allocation theory, the notion that you maintain a fixed percentage balance between stocks and bonds. Our stocks had outperformed bonds and I recall the feeling of pleasure, of being smart, when I moved money from stocks to bonds. Since then, the stock market has done nothing but go up. Sigh.
The Good Greatsby
February 28, 2017
It took a lot of years to stop going shopping if we didn’t have anything specific we were looking for. It’s a sure sign we were going to buy something that would feel exciting for a moment but spend years gathering dust.
Sorry to hear about your portfolio. I hope that doesn’t affect your plans to make vacation plans.
Jim Wheeler
February 28, 2017
Nah. I’m split 50/50, so my only problem is greed. : )
nicolesundays
February 28, 2017
Why stop there? Personally, I’d be even more content to not only not have to go on a trip, but also be absolved from the responsibility of making plans. Family/friends do the work and I just have to visualize the commitment of having fun before embracing reality.
Also, that mug idea is a game-changer–the possibilities are at once endless and diminished!
The Good Greatsby
February 28, 2017
It’s a pretty significant financial savings to be able to get a Sydney Starbucks mug without flying to Australia. It’s about $1800 cheaper. The Australian tourism board might want to have a word with Starbucks.
Elyse
February 28, 2017
And all the while I thought I was just anti-social!
The Good Greatsby
February 28, 2017
Sounds like you were just a forward thinker. Technology and science are finally catching up with you.
iksperimentalist
February 28, 2017
Another good way to amplify this effect is to invite someone else to go on the vacation with you …. The trick is to find out in advance that they can,t go ….. You offer to buy them round trip tickets to Hawaii and pay for the resorts, etc … be sure you do it at the last minute …. at a time when you know it would be impossible for them to go …. When they turn you down you can change your plans and get double the benefit.
The Good Greatsby
February 28, 2017
You have no idea how many times I’ve offered to come to a friend’s thing the minute I hear from a second friend that the thing has been cancelled. Social media is also great for letting you know when people are out of town so you can text them about getting together tonight to catch up.
Mark Petruska
February 28, 2017
This is why I only commit to things when the odds of them falling through greatly outweighs the chances that I’ll actually have to follow through. Like, I’ll tell somebody I’m happy to help them move after the NWS has just issued a Blizzard Warning for that day. In fact, the worse the impending natural disaster, the quicker I am to offer my help (and the more ebullient my attitude is)!
The Good Greatsby
March 1, 2017
This is my first year living somewhere with a mild winter since I was a kid. Part of me appreciates the lack of seasonal depression, and part of me misses being able to use the weather to get out of things.
aFrankAngle
February 28, 2017
Love the concept of Good Intentions … and following through with those intentions is personally rewarding. In terms of Meetup, I know a little about it, but have never used it. But I know it’s a way to connect on various levels.
The Good Greatsby
March 1, 2017
Give Meetup a try. It’s so easy to get started making and canceling plans.
Gabe Burkhardt
February 28, 2017
I’m a huge fan of quitting. I quit as many things as I can, as often as I can. Leaves me more time to do the things I will probably finish (or enjoy).
Calling it Good Intentions is a lot more palatable than Quitter. And you get Starbucks souvenirs (even if ordered online) out of the deal. Personally, I’m a MCDonald’s guy. The best one I’ve been to is on the Champs L-EE-say in Paris. Pricey, but totally worth the 12 Euro for the L’Big Mac menu because they let you keep the box.
The Good Greatsby
March 1, 2017
Knowing when to quit is a valuable life skill. We invest so much in the idea that we should follow through on everything and never quit that we have a hard time quitting when something is clearly not worth our time. I can’t tell you how many times people tell me they hate the book they’re reading but can’t quit because they’ve already invested 100 pages of time.
Ankur Mithal
February 28, 2017
You are on to something. Human beings’ unnatural tendency to evolve will only release more endorphins from this technique. Imagine a day when all you need to do is plan to make a plan, not actually make it, that you were going to cancel.
List of X
March 1, 2017
And I guess your computer gives you occasional quick endorphin rushed when asks if you want to install this or that unnecessary program or update, and gives you an option to cancel.
The Good Greatsby
March 1, 2017
I do like disappointing the computer. I experience a thrill every time I put a stop to its diabolical, train-of-thought-interrupting update plans.
She's a Maineiac
March 1, 2017
Ah, man! There is NOTHING more satisfying than when they cancel your son’s soccer game! The stuff dreams are made of. I look forward to the day when I can do everything while sitting. Maybe get one of those fancy spinning chairs like on The Voice so I can just shout commands to my robot butler. Make him attend all those LuLaRoe parties.
The great thing about technology and social media is all you have to do is stop posting/commenting/liking stuff for a few days and everyone thinks you’re dead. Good way to get out of moving a friend’s couch.
pegoleg
March 1, 2017
Thank God, Darla. Hadn’t heard from you in 3 days and I thought you were dead!
She's a Maineiac
March 2, 2017
Dammit! My cover’s blown! (But you know I’d always make time to move a couch for you, Peggles)
pegoleg
March 2, 2017
Apropos of nothing, it just so happens I’m leaving my office in 1/2 hour to go home to let the guys in who are delivering, wait for it…our new couch.
silkpurseproductions
March 1, 2017
Damn! You have just given He-Who the best excuse ever for consistently making plans for us to go on a trip and then cancelling as I am mentally packing my bags. I have to hide this post from him.
The Good Greatsby
March 1, 2017
I’m not sure he needs this post as an excuse. It certainly sounds like he’s already been aware of this concept for years.
silkpurseproductions
March 1, 2017
Sneaky bugger, he probably was.
Kate Crimmins
March 1, 2017
You make me feel so normal. I once volunteered to help a friend move and didn’t show up. Since I’m not that kind of person, I had to get sick to do it. I much prefer the planning aspect of a vacation than the actual going (so annoying…packing, airlines, flying, unknown roads, airlines….) The best vacation is a short trip to the beach — sun, surf and I know how to get there. If only they had Starbucks I’d be set.
The Good Greatsby
March 1, 2017
The ability to summon illness to avoid work is an impressive skill. Does the illness maintain a natural three-day life cycle, or does it seem to clear up the moment the last box is unpacked?
Kate Crimmins
March 1, 2017
It stayed until the next morning when a miracle happened and I was cured. I never used this power again although I kept it in my box of tricks.
pegoleg
March 1, 2017
My personal road to hell is sure to be paved with good intentions. But I congratulate myself for showing enough initiative to get it paved – so many people have dirt roads to hell.
The Good Greatsby
March 1, 2017
It’s true we seldom differentiate between the quality of that road to good intentions. Society has to find a better way to judge between figurative paved roads and dirt roads or the well-intentioned will lose all incentive to put on a good show.
Lorna's Voice
March 1, 2017
I was going to write a witty response, but something came up (other than a witty response). I don’t see a “cancel” button, so I guess I’ll have to post this…
decadentlife
March 2, 2017
And then there is the secret hoping that the event is cancelled on Facebook due to lack of interest. Everyone always indicates ‘interested,’ but then nobody commits to ‘going.’
The Good Greatsby
March 2, 2017
Yeah, the ‘interested’ category is pretty misleading. It’s hard to plan an event around ‘interested’. It’s the absolute minimum benchmark of commitment.
Exile on Pain Street
March 2, 2017
Today, we’re called slackers. It has a poetic panache to it. When I was in my 20s, I was LAZY. It’s not as attractive. If you’re lazy, nobody will hire you, pretty girls won’t kiss you and you’re not taken seriously by anyone. Today, a guy who’s a slacker can probably find a girl slacker to make out with. No such luck when I was young.
Talasi Guerra
March 4, 2017
This is fantastic. Well said!
JaeSpotMediaGroup
March 5, 2017
Commitments
Barb
March 6, 2017
I actually give myself a little pep talk before I travel, reminding myself to LET GO! Walk out into the world expecting to miss connections, get lost, and interact with people who think Americans are rude. This way, I’m always pleasantly surprised and a lot more open to the quinky dinks…and if I need a piece of “home”…there’s always Starbucks.