
For any international readers not familiar with American Thanksgiving, the simplest explanation is to think of it as a day when family gathers from far and wide to celebrate the great American tradition of overeating.
Thanksgiving is a special day when hearts swell with gratitude…also with the symptoms of heart disease.
Swelling of the stomach can also be expected. Also hands–you might want to take off any rings before sitting down.
The brain’s shame center also experiences some swelling–make sure and take group photos before dinner because those post-dinner hound-dog expressions of shame can’t be edited out with Photoshop.
The origins of the first Thanksgiving are still in dispute, but apparently the Pilgrims came to America to pursue their religious right to continue eating beyond the point of being full. The Pilgrims were persecuted for challenging the Church of England’s long-standing doctrine that a man should cease eating once he felt full or at the very least once he felt dizzy, nauseous, or passed out. The Pilgrims believed the feeling of being full was merely a mile marker along the path to digestive glory, and if we were truly grateful for the meal God had provided, we would show that gratitude by eating three dinners–one for each member of the holy trinity.
The actual menu served at the first Thanksgiving is also widely disputed, and this uncertainty has only increased the tendency to overeat. Some scholars say the Pilgrims ate turkey, wild goose, and venison. Some sources say eel, or bass, or cod. Some less reputable sources–like me–say Sasquatch and pterodactyl. But because nobody is certain, we’ve compensated by eating one of every single type of food the Pilgrims may have eaten or would have eaten if seven-layer dip had existed in Pilgrim times.
As the story goes, Pilgrims were near starvation during their first year and the Wampanoag Native Americans taught them how to fish and gave them seeds. The second year was much more prosperous, and the Pilgrims invited the Native Americans to join them for a giant feast. The Wampanoag would come to regret their attendance when their chief Massasoit and Governor Bradford reached for the last turkey drumstick at the same time and the two men agreed Massasoit could have it in exchange for his continent.
In defense of the Pilgrims taking the land of the people who saved them from starvation, it should be noted the Native Americans were sitting on some pretty great land. When the Pilgrims learned Mount Rushmore contained the images of four of our future presidents, it was hard not to feel a sense of ownership.
Thanksgiving also marks the beginning of the holidays, the Christmas shopping season, and a dramatic six-week gaining of weight. For those people watching their weight and who spent the previous ten and a half months losing the weight gained during last year’s series of seasonal dinners, Thanksgiving is a reminder that the entire world is against you.
Gobble.
nuvofelt
November 22, 2011
How did the old song go?
‘It’s illegal, it’s immoral, or it makes you fat!’
The Good Greatsby
November 22, 2011
That must be a pretty old song.
ajg
November 24, 2011
It’s jaunty. I sing it to the tune of The Facts of Life theme.
visitingmissouri
November 22, 2011
Now I finally get it. Thank you so much. What a great country you have.
nuvofelt
November 22, 2011
No, not pretty old….. VERY old
georgettesullins
November 22, 2011
At least the Pilgrims didn’t also have to contribute to the office feast which includes waking up in the middle of the night remembering “Oh no!, I gotta bring something. Okay what is there? 2 cans of beans, 1 can of Campbell’s cream of mushroom soup,…what no dried onions…crumble up some toast crumbs…voilá topping!”
The Good Greatsby
November 22, 2011
Avoiding office feasts and office Secret Santas are another reason why the Pilgrims left England.
bigsheepcommunications
November 22, 2011
“the path to digestive glory” – now there’s an inspiring phrase : )
The Good Greatsby
November 22, 2011
I think I read that in the Pilgrim translation of the bible.
becomingcliche
November 22, 2011
I believe I have an actual photograph taken in pilgrim times that shows a 7 layer dip and a cold relish tray. And a kids’ table.
The Good Greatsby
November 22, 2011
That picture of the seven-layer dip will only serve to fuel conspiracy theories. It will make Thanksgiving guests even less likely to believe my claims of inventing seven-layer dip.
Kathryn McCullough
November 22, 2011
Oh, so sadly true. I say where’s my girdle, girdle?
Glynis Sylvia
November 23, 2011
So THAT’s what turkey’s really are saying !!!! Not “gobble gobble”.
Snoring Dog Studio
November 22, 2011
From now on, I will only come here for lessons in history. After reading this, I’m left with the image of the male Pilgrims sitting by the fire, one hand tucked inside their pants, belching. These are fine traditions.
thoughtsappear
November 22, 2011
You know, pterodactyl makes so much sense. I’m going to serve that next year. Where can I get one?
Spectra
November 24, 2011
Right here in New Jersey
http://spectrumwoman.com/2011/10/03/the-jersey-devil-abides/
And here’s some alternative Dinosaur Meat, in case you have taken a moral stance against eating the endangered Pteradactyl…http://spectrumwoman.com/2011/10/18/proof-that-dinosaurs-still-exist/
gerknoop
November 22, 2011
“and if we were truly grateful for the meal God had provided, we would show that gratitude by eating three dinners–one for each member of the holy trinity”.
I am of this religious ilk…. LOLOLOLOLOL!!! & Throwing my head back again this morning in laughter! Also loved the Mt. Rushmore line!
Laura
November 22, 2011
The tradition in my family is that everyone brings some food to Thanksgiving dinner — which is great, but we tend to go a little overboard. We actually had to institute the rule that you can’t bring more than your own body weight in food.
True confession: when I was a kid, I believed that Mt. Rushmore was naturally shaped that way, and the resemblance to the presidents was just a coincidence.
The Good Greatsby
November 23, 2011
I also thought the mountain was naturally shaped that way. It was hard to believe humans were capable of carving up a mountain like that.
shreejacob
November 22, 2011
Hmmm sounds like every religious festival, wedding ceremony and what not in Malaysia,not the Sasquatch and pterodactyl though and not the cod as well..its expensive here. The rest..yup.
susielindau
November 22, 2011
I will take your advice about the rings…Happy Thanksgiving!
pattisj
November 22, 2011
You should have been a history teacher. I much prefer your version.
thelifeofjamie
November 22, 2011
That is what is missing from the history books…pilgrims came here to exercise their religious rights to be full and more. Where were you in history class? I was daydreaming most of the time so I probably wouldn’t have noticed you anyway.
pegoleg
November 22, 2011
Paul, I think that last line is speaking directly to me. I’m doooooomed!
The Good Greatsby
November 22, 2011
Tell everyone you’re not celebrating the holidays this year and won’t accept any invitations to dinner.
pegoleg
November 23, 2011
I told everyone I’ve become a Wiccan and don’t celebrate Christmas, but what about Thanksgiving? Everybody’s coming to my house. Should I renounce my US citizenship and move to Cuba?
She's a Maineiac
November 23, 2011
Oh, no, you’re fine, Peg. It was obviously directed to me. The world is out to get me. So I’ve given up already. I polished off an entire pumpkin pie this morning for breakfast.
Tori Nelson
November 22, 2011
I like sing the song “Savages” from Disney’s Pocahontas during Thanksgiving dinner. It’s catchy, I enjoy singing in a British accent, and it’s good for kid’s to learn early that white folks is whack and you can always eat a meal with the enemy… It’s the American way!
Hillary Manaster
November 23, 2011
I was wondering….do you have a children’s picture book version of the tale?
Lenore Diane
November 23, 2011
Gosh Paul, you wrote like a Debbie Downer. The way you described the Pilgrims and Thanksgiving … well, I’ve lost my appetite. Then again, we started eating this morning, so maybe I’m full.
*burp*
‘Scuse me.
The Good Greatsby
November 23, 2011
I wasn’t trying to be a downer; I actually hoped knowing the true origins of Thanksgiving would decrease the overeating guilt.
Jackie Cangro
November 23, 2011
I have to make one correction: the Christmas shopping season begins after Halloween, not after Thanksgiving.
Ho, Ho, Ho!
Glynis Sylvia
November 23, 2011
Christmas shopping season is scheduled for next year, two Fridays after LENT.
The Good Greatsby
November 23, 2011
It’s going to start on New Year’s Day before too long.
cooper
November 23, 2011
As the story goes, Pilgrims were near starvation during their first year and the Wampanoag Native Americans taught them how to fish and gave them seeds. The second year was much more prosperous, and the Pilgrims invited the Native Americans to join them for a giant feast.
They fed ’em, then kicked their asses across the country….
The Good Greatsby
November 23, 2011
The Pilgrims knew it would be harder for them to run on a full stomach.
Lenore Diane
November 23, 2011
Hahahaha! That’s funny! Plus, the turkey has tryptophane…. it slows the opponent.
Ahmnodt Heare
November 23, 2011
Thank you for clearing up the origins of Thanksgiving. I thought it was an NFL-created holiday as an excuse to have football on Thursday afternoons.
The Good Greatsby
November 23, 2011
That’s a reason I can really get behind.
Renée A. Schuls-Jacobson
November 23, 2011
It is my understanding that pterodactyl goes great with the seven layer dip. This year I have to make five pounds of mashed potatoes. What if I just bring celery? That would be so much easier.
The Good Greatsby
November 23, 2011
I remember that’s what I always used to hear from all the kids at the kids’ table: “I sure wish somebody had brought some celery.”
Angie Z.
November 23, 2011
I can’t help but think of the Abraham Lincoln proclamation that supposedly started the national holiday of Thanksgiving, stating Americans had become materialistic, greedy, had fallen away from God and therefore needed a day set aside to reflect on those things. It certainly makes sense to me that this day is now the kick-off of Black Friday.
The Good Greatsby
November 23, 2011
Seems like a day of fasting or making some effort to do without would do more to remind us to be thankful.
philosophermouseofthehedge
November 23, 2011
Great post! A real feast for the funny bone. Better than a tofu turkey donated by PETA
Emily Cannell
November 23, 2011
I really only like to eat the turkey leg- like a Viking. It`s much harder to eat the jello mold with fingers so I just stick to the turkey leg now.
Hansi
November 23, 2011
That was the best description of American Thanksgiving I’ve ever read. Not only were all the trimmings included but you’ve also added side-dishes of Parody, Sarcasm, Sacrilege and Blasphemy to make it a true American holiday.
PCC Advantage
November 24, 2011
Thank goodness we Canadians celebrate Thanksgiving the at the beginning of October…gives me time to lose some weight,put away my Thanksgiving pants, dress like a normal human being again, and then put on a bit more weight in time for my Christmas pants collection.
You poor Americans…2 big holidays so close to each other! I don’t know how you do it… 😉
pegoleg
November 24, 2011
Spandex – the American’s best friend.
Spectra
November 24, 2011
This was great! But it makes you wonder about letting hungry people make big business decisions. Trading a whole continent for a turkey leg just doesn’t seem like a sound business decision.
The Hook
November 24, 2011
Congrats on the well-deserved recognition, O Great One!
Just remember who your friends are when your plan for world domination reaches fruition!
societyred
November 24, 2011
OK, I’m convinced, you’re funny! And I love finding new sources of humor.
Thanks!