
As a child I remember being reprimanded a lot for not listening, as though turning off my ears had been a conscious decision. Adults swore they had told me something important, and I had nodded acknowledgement, but all details of the conversation eluded me. I remember a lot of conversations ending with, “Do you understand what I just told you?” or “Did you hear me?” and I knew I should always nod yes, even though I had no idea what had come before these questions.
This is why I don’t blame my seven-year-old, The Fonz, when he says he didn’t hear me calling his name or telling him not to eat out of the garbage, because I understand. What I don’t understand is why he seems to have supersonic hearing for some noises–like the opening of a candy wrapper, while tuning out other noises–like the sound of his name.
I am absolutely not exaggerating when I say The Fonz can hear candy being opened on the first floor while he is in his room on the third floor. We know because Mrs. Good Greatsby and I have actually conducted experiments. We’ll sit at the kitchen table on the first floor while The Fonz is on the third floor, tear open a corner of a Skittles wrapper, and he’ll come bounding down the stairs within five seconds.
“Hey, guys. Just came downstairs to give you a hug. Whatcha eatin’?”
The next night we’ll tear corners from a piece of printer paper. No Fonz.
We’ll crinkle aluminum foil. No Fonz.
We’ll tear strips of cardboard. No Fonz.
We’ll tear a corner of an m&m’s wrapper and within seconds we’ll hear the sound of The Fonz bounding down the steps and landing with a thud on the landing after clearing the last six stairs in one leap.
“Hey, guys. Whatcha eatin’?”
If we’re watching a movie as a family and eating popcorn, and I very slowly sneak an m&m, convinced no one has heard any difference in crunch volume, he slowly rotates his head around from its favorite position blocking the TV from the rest of us, arches his eyebrow and shoots me a cold look that sends chills down my spine.
If I drink soda while he’s away at school, I put a towel over the top of the can to muffle the opening pop–even though he’s miles away, but still when he gets home he asks what I did at work that day with a certain inflection that tells me he heard. He always hears.
Just like some sounds attract The Fonz, some sounds repel. When Mrs. Good Greatsby and I want some privacy to discuss Christmas presents, The Fonz’s birthday, or new ideas for embarrassing him in front of the girl he likes, we just start clanking the dishes together in the sink like we’re about to ask somebody to wash them, and he goes running like he’s heard a fire alarm.
We’ve also found the tearing of a garbage bag’s perforated edge as it’s pulled from the roll–warning him somebody is about to be asked to take out the trash–is the quickest way to convince him to jump into the bath as a defense against us asking him.
And here’s the kicker, here’s the things that amazes me, here’s the thing I need science to explain. How can The Fonz achieve such feats of supersonic hearing yet he can’t hear his name called to him repeatedly from two feet away? “Fonz. Fonz. Over here. Over here. Look up. Look over at dad. Fonz! Fonz!”
What accounts for this selective hearing? How come he can hear a candy wrapper being opened from the third floor, but he can’t hear me calling his name from the second floor? My wife and I considered opening a package of m&m’s every time we wanted him to come running, but we counted the number of times we weren’t able to get his attention per day and realized the cumulative cost of the m&m’s would be more than we planned to spend on his college education.
We’ve decided we can only use the m&m’s in case of emergency and instead of hiding a key under a rock in our front yard, we’ve hidden m&m’s, just in case there’s a fire and we need The Fonz to wake up and shimmy two floors down the drainpipe, taking the final floor in one single shimmy.
ryoko861
October 13, 2011
It’s called “convenient hearing loss” or just “convenient hearing”.
“Clean your room” will go on deaf ears.
The sound of a candy wrapper coming from the kitchen-he’ll be there in a New York minute!
It doesn’t get any better either as they get older.
gerknoop
October 13, 2011
Perhaps I never grew up because my husband tells me that I have selective hearing…..however I don’t think I ever possessed the great talent that the Fonz does for hearing the candy wrapper open. That is one special talent!
The Good Greatsby
October 14, 2011
I’d be more excited about his special talent if I could think of a way to make some money from it.
bigsheepcommunications
October 13, 2011
Must be a boy thing – I actually had my son tested by an audiologist when he was about 7 years old because I was afraid he really was hard of hearing. Nope.
At the other end of the spectrum, my daughter can literally HEAR something as subtle as a change in my facial expression. Seriously scary.
The Good Greatsby
October 14, 2011
That is actually scary. The idea of your daughter hearing your facial expression could be a truly effective image in a horror movie.
Joy
October 13, 2011
Man, I have one of those at my house. The sugar junkie. She has the same supersonic hearing when it comes to the candy wrapper but also has the sixth candy is in this house sense. Then the search is on…
Erin McNaughton
October 13, 2011
I have to admit, I’ve got the sixth sense for candy as well. It makes life pretty sweet, until you’re caught purusing someone’s cabinent for the first time.
She's a Maineiac
October 13, 2011
Oh how I can relate to this one. Just yesterday I must have yelled my son’s name at the top of my lungs directly into his ear and he didn’t even flinch. Just kept staring straight ahead in a Mario-induced coma. But if I open up a bag of chips, he’s suddenly right there like the Flash. He can also hear us whispering two floors down if we mention the words: candy, Christmas, Wii or Mario. Creepy stuff I tells ya.
pegoleg
October 13, 2011
Have you had any food or rest since yesterday, o Freshly Pressed one?
She's a Maineiac
October 14, 2011
Oh, sure. I just put on one of those beer can hats, put a diet Coke and a can of spray cheese in there and I was good to go.
pegoleg
October 13, 2011
Are you worried that the Fonz’s reaction to snack-sneaking-while-TV-viewing bears a frightening resemblance to a young Voldemort?
The Good Greatsby
October 14, 2011
I am now.
thelifeofjamie
October 13, 2011
I can just see his head rotating 180 degrees when you eat M&M’s while watching tv. You should consider calling the company and see if they can start storing things in the m&M bags for you. Tear open a bag, “watcha eating?” oh it’s a lovely brussel sprout!
pegoleg
October 13, 2011
Genius.
The Good Greatsby
October 14, 2011
I’m sure I could find a way to reseal m&m’s packaging after inserting some vegetables or medicine inside.
Louise
October 14, 2011
I can totally relate. My boys are still young but it’s the same thing with the chocolate and candy. They tune out for clean up time, brush teeth time and finish your vegetable time.
Thanks for sharing!
Cheers,
Louise
Callsign Mommy
October 14, 2011
It seems that all men have this selective hearing (as evidenced by the hubs and his boisterous offspring, Lunchbox and Turbo). I think it becomes even more fine tuned when the voice it is “not” hearing is female…
Kathryn McCullough
October 14, 2011
Was there an instance of Freshly Pressing that I didn’t hear about?
pegoleg
October 14, 2011
I’m referring to She’s a Mainiac – she’s hangin’ up on the front page for all to see, as we type!
Spectra
October 14, 2011
My cat did this, only replace M & M’s with cans of tuna. She could be comatose 4 rooms away, and I merely opened a cabinet and touched a can of tuna…she’d come running, twitiching her tail in that way that let me know she knew what type of can that was. She didn’t do this for beans, corn, clams, or tomato paste…only tuna. my guess? They are all psychic and can read our minds. em> There is no other explanation!
The Good Greatsby
October 14, 2011
I also witnessed my first cat doing this. There must be something different about the sound of tuna cans.
PCC Advantage
October 14, 2011
I understand selective hearing all too well! To this day, I try REALLY hard to listen and (apparently) when someone says, “Do you understand?”, I always nod to indicate that, “Yes, I do. I understand exactly what you just told me”, and then when they mention something further on the topic, I tell them I have no idea what they’re talking about.
Hmm…maybe that’s no so much selective hearing as it is Alzheimer’s. I should have that looked at.
Or maybe everyone should just give me Skittles when they want me to listen to something. I’m sure that’d work too…
Invisible Mikey
October 14, 2011
Both the dog and the alpha cat stop still *BANG* if they hear anything anywhere in the house that sounds remotely like kibble being poured into a dish. Perhaps your son is in touch with his animal nature.
Laura
October 14, 2011
This might just be a simple misunderstanding. He’s never actually said he heard a candy wrapper or soda can, right? You might want to check your house for hidden cameras.
torcon1
October 14, 2011
G2, It seems that science is on the side of your boy. Us “Y” chromosome types only use half our brain when listening, while women use both hemispheres. I actually blogged about this today in light of how much more goodlier women communicate than men….
http://bit.ly/pQGuqb
The Good Greatsby
October 14, 2011
I just read your post and because I’ve done some work in organizational behavior, I’ve always been interested in studies showing women appear to be better communicators and managers in many different types of management situations.
I haven’t been able to leave comments on your site the last few weeks. Every time it gives me a message in the comment box that reads: Please wait…, but it never finishes loading.
John Erickson
October 14, 2011
No kids, but dogs and cats, and they’re all guilty. WAY beyond a Pavlovian response. Especially Max the cat, who walks into the kitchen and calls YOU to HIM.
Our pets are well trained….
The Good Greatsby
October 14, 2011
I completely understand because my cat, Megatron, is calling me even as I write this.
Snoring Dog Studio
October 14, 2011
It’s a scientific fact: Little boys have the same acute sense of hearing as do dogs. It is only when the boys become men and get married do they lose this super sense in its entirety.
mistyslaws
October 14, 2011
I suggest using an empty M&M wrapper and tearing off little pieces of the wrapper every time you want him to hear you. It’s called recycling, duh. Unless it only works with a full bag. His hearing may be fine tuned to the difference. You may need to do another test study. If you can use an empty one, that will save you money. It’s like being earth conscious while also being sneaky bastards. Win-win, I say.
pattisj
October 15, 2011
Did i hear someone open a bag of M&Ms? Share?
S. Trevor Swenson
October 16, 2011
My moms and I had a discussion of this sort in the past year or so. She accused me of not listening to her. Ever defiant, I repeated everything she had just said. I told her that I HEAR her just fine, I just don’t give her the response ( usually some sort of obedience) that she wants.
“Well you need to HEAR and to MIND me”
“Yeah Ma, that’s not going to happen.”
I also love to pull the timeless rude gesture on her by pointing the remote control at her while she is yapping at me and asking “Is there anything lower than “mute”? She actually hit me for that once when I was 35. Women ( girlfriends, wives, mothers etc don;t respond well to the remote/mute joke)
It blew my mind years later after watching all those Peanuts TV specials during the 70s and 80s how brilliant Charles Schultz was by having the adults sound like “Wah wah wah wah wahhh wahhhh” to all the Peanuts gang.