
As a kid I enjoyed collecting coins until I learned I could lose those collected coins through a hole in my pocket. I also learned I could lose an older brother’s coin collection through a hole in my pocket. I also learned I could place the last remaining coin in my little brother’s pocket and everyone would believe he was to blame because he usually was to blame. The US Federal Reserve is tasked with developing new ideas for coins that will appeal to coin enthusiasts and earn revenue when those collectors remove the money from circulation, and whether those coin collectors keep those collections in a jar, or a display case, or a pocket with a hole in it is up to the individual collector and outside the specific responsibility of the Fed.
The government has spent decades trying to figure out how to convince the American people to use the $1 coin, but their strategy often begins and ends with ex-presidents, a source of inspiration that appears to be running dry as evidenced by the next series of coins under consideration:
1. Presidents wearing hats
2. Presidential dogs
3. Presidential dogs wearing hats
4. Presidents and their dogs shopping for hats
5. Presidents and their dogs recreating famous hat scenes from classic American films
(These ideas started as a joke, but to be honest I would collect every single one of these coins.)
To make these $1 coins popular the government needs to concentrate on the reasons people collect other items like stamps, baseball cards, or husbands. Allow me to make some suggestions for coins I feel would achieve greater popularity.
Famous celebrity couples: Collect Elizabeth Taylor and her seven husbands. The quantity of coins printed for each husband would be proportional to the length of time they were married. Richard Burton would get the most coins because he and Taylor were married eleven years while Nicky Hilton would get relatively few because they were only married for nine months. The scarcity of Nicky Hilton would make this a difficult set to complete and therefore drive public interest.
Famous coin collectors: Is there a Michael Jordan of coin collecting? I’m sure coin collectors must have a famous collector or collectors they idolize above all others. Let’s put those guys on a coin. The coin collecting community would go crazy for these.
Boy band series: Collect all the members of the Backstreet Boys, N’SYNC, and New Kids on the Block. But there’s a catch: No Justin Timberlake. Fans would search everywhere for JT, desperately hoping to complete the set. They would keep collecting more and more coins, and in a way this would be a tax on the type of people who annoy me.
Collecting: If you want to appeal to the type of people who collect, why not celebrate the human concept of collecting with a series of coins featuring stamp collections, baseball cards, and Cracker Jack prizes?
Famous coins: My friend Andrew suggested a series of coins commemorating old coins no longer in distribution. Or how about a series of $1 coins commemorating other current coins like the penny, dime, and quarter?

Does anyone know where I can find these dollar sign money sacks? I would love to carry my money around in these.
Horoscope: Every month a new horoscope is introduced. I would be willing to write these and would excel at making eerily accurate but obvious observations like, “You are very near a Wal-Mart.”
If the Federal Reserve has no interest in any of these ideas, at the very least please start giving out the $1 coins in those money sacks with the dollar sign on the outside. I would take enough coins to fill two sacks for that reason alone.
ryoko861
June 30, 2011
Love those ideas! Schwarzenegger came to mine….all the children he fathered along with their mothers.
Matt Appling
June 30, 2011
That’s why Sacajawea never took off. She wasn’t wearing a hat!
Todd Pack
June 30, 2011
This is what I don’t understand: If the government wants people to use dollar coins instead of dollar bills, then STOP PRINTING DOLLAR BILLS.
The Good Greatsby
June 30, 2011
Exactly. I think every other government that converted coins to bills either cut bills off completely or slowly phased them out.
gardenmad
June 30, 2011
I’m with Todd. It just seems too easy. But hey, it’s big government. It’s necessary to reinvent the wheel. Besides, wouldn’t it be fun to say “Is that a roll of Sacajawea’s in your pocket, or are you just glad to see me?”
Brown Road Chronicles
June 30, 2011
I know you end some of your posts with a quote about “stupid questions”. I can’t remember the exact quote but here’s my stupid question of the day. I don’t understand how the government makes money by collectors taking money out of circulation. I must have slept through that topic during the couple of economics classes I took. Actually I think I slept through most of those classes. In any case, can someone smarter than me please ‘splain it?
The Good Greatsby
June 30, 2011
If a collector exchanges a $1 bill or 4 quarters or 100 pennies for a $1 coin and keeps the coin in his collection and never spends it again then this $1 coin theoretically disappears as far as the government is concerned. That $1 coin should be a claim against $1 of the government’s assets but if the collector never uses the $1 coin it’s like the government received cash in exchange for a check that will never be deposited.
When the government did the state quarters program they estimated $4.6 billion coins were removed from circulation and would never return, so in essence the government received $4.6 billion in cash from collectors for a $4.6 billion theoretical check that will never be cashed.
pegoleg
June 30, 2011
Wow. Paul…you’re smart! All that and devilish smoking jacket good looks, too. Who knew?
The Good Greatsby
June 30, 2011
I’m flattered. When I applied for the IMF director job I probably should have mentioned my bachelors degree is in Finance. Maybe then I would have received an interview. Or even a reply email.
pegoleg
July 1, 2011
Hey, me too – from Michigan State. How did we get here? Did you take “Humor Blogging for Finance Majors 401?”
Meet the Buttrams
June 30, 2011
They would reach an entirely new market of collectors if they commemorated Beanie Babies. Or troll dolls. Pet rocks maybe? I think I’m on to something.
torcon1
June 30, 2011
I avoid the weighty issue of carrying coins at all costs – “pants on the ground” is no longer in vogue…
The Good Greatsby
July 1, 2011
And too many coins in the pockets make you look and sound like an idiot if you have to run.
thelifeofjamie
June 30, 2011
I have tried to pay with a 1 dollar coin before and the people don’t know what it is and won’t let you pay. It’s easier to hand them a bill than watch them flip the coin over and over trying to figure out it’s worth with a perplexed look on their face.
The Good Greatsby
July 1, 2011
Isn’t it amazing that a country could issue billions of coins and much of the general population wouldn’t recognize or accept it as currency?
girlonthecontrary
June 30, 2011
Listen, the if “the man” wants us to use $1 coins, all he has to do is totally get behind the theory that the world is going to end/apocalypse will ensue on December 21, 2012. And say that there is no way paper money is going to be worth anything after that, coins will be the most valuable currency. People would be buying coins up like crazy. Duh. You’re welcome government. And, if the world doesn’t end and people get pissed, well, you can just chock it up to typical government lies.
The Good Greatsby
July 1, 2011
If girlonthecontrary says the world is coming to an end, that’s all the evidence I need.
Dana
June 30, 2011
I live in Canada and received a $1 US coin as change for a purchase without realizing it until it was too late. Now I can’t spend the stupid coin here OR in the USA apparently (with Americans being allergic to $1 coins and all.) I have inadvertently took it out of circulation. You’re welcome, US government.
Spectra
June 30, 2011
These are all fiscally sound ideas, and will no doubt generate much “needed” revenue to help fund the recent muti-million $$ bonus our representatives just voted into effect for themselves, while tryng dutifully to engineer new and exciting ways to screw our Senior Citizens out of already sub-par health care, teachers and schools, and you, the little guy…
In my efforts to assist my leaders in their plans to pilfer and pillage the masses, while exhalting the corporations, who they also voted to allow unlimited campaign contributions (to their own campaigns) I have a few suggestions.
Bank Robbers: minting coins that exhault famous theives would be a big “seller”. Who doesn’t froth at the mouth with want of a Bonnie and Clyde dollar coin? Jimmy “Legs” Diamond? Billy the Kid. It’s reflective of the American Way. And what Irony there would be when a Bank Robber robs a vault full of $ coins pressed with images of Bank Robbers!
Famous Bailout Recipients: Those AIG quarters would fly off the mints shelves. General Motors, too, especially if they feature coins with their entire failed line of cars. And over paid, over-bonused CEO’s.
Rappers: c’mon…do I really need to explain this one? Who doesnt want to collect the P. Diddy series? with his ever-changing names, one is sure to be rare. “You got a Puffy, Man? I gives you twunty Bonnie n Clydes fo a Puffy, sheeit”.
Celebrities who Failed Recovery; we may like winners, but we LOVE a failure. Paris Hilton, Lindsey Lohan, Britainy Spears, Mickey Rourke. Rush Limbaugh.
Murderers; why not? If they’re famous, Just Mint ’em! I want to be the first to collect the O.J., the Robert Blake, The Specter. Cool!
These are just a few, but you can see my Patriotism shining through here.
This was truely an inspiring post 😉
The Good Greatsby
July 1, 2011
The bank robber series could also have pictures of current wanted criminals. This would help the FBI capture their 10 most wanted.
Tyler
June 30, 2011
Maybe a collection of Limited Edition coin dollars, shaped like dollars. Make big metal rectangular coin-dollars with a hinge in the middle. I think this is almost necessary with the deterioration of phones with hinges. We need the flip.
Renee Davies
June 30, 2011
Canada used to circulate $1 and $2 bills, until they replaced them with $1 and $2 coins, calling them loonies and toonies respectively. I’m not sure if someone is trying to hurry us up into a digital monetary system or if someone at the Royal Canadian Mint has a thing for WB Looney Tunes, but my purse can be a hefty thing to carry when I do commerce in Canada.
HoaiPhai
July 5, 2011
As a Canadian, I do commerce all the time here and the coins are not a problem at all. Insecure people carry their loonies around in a leather sock when shopping, which comes in handy if you’re mugged. Since the loonies and twonies were introduced, the incidence of muggings have dropped off rather sharply.
I think that the reason why the dollar coins have not been embraced by Americans while Canadians took to them with hardly a protest is because of the images of the presidents. Here a portrait of the Queen is found on all these coins. What can I say? I guess sex sells. Maybe you just need to spruce up the appearence of your presidents.
limr
July 1, 2011
My parents tried to encourage me to collect coins when I was a child, but I quickly lost interest when I realized how difficult it was to sqeeze the coins into those tiny little slots in the folders they bought me. I had collected about $2.40 in dimes and quarters which I ultimately spent on ice cream.
I may be persuaded to try a coin collection again, however, if they could do a Parts of Speech series of dollars. Or perhaps a Great Irregular Verbs series.
spilledinkguy
July 1, 2011
Except I’m never recirculating my boy-band coins.
I’m ‘keeps’ en um.
I’ll paste them to my walls. Next to my Tiger Beat posters.
Who knew the US mint could be such a dreamy place!
🙂
bschooled
July 1, 2011
I think they should make coins depicting the Bachelorette and ones that say “Finding True Love on A Reality Show”. Then you have to match the Bachelorette coins with the true love coins.
Only what people won’t realize is that there aren’t any “finding true love on a reality show” coins. I just made it up.
gardenmad
July 1, 2011
This is my second comment on this post. Obviously I’m giving this way too much thought. But it’s so exciting…..what about sports teams!!! NFL, MLB, wow….you could do coins for each player on each team, or even just each major league franchise. Then whichever team wins their respective title…..Super Bowl, World Series…..well, those coins would really be in demand.
Memo to self….get a life!
ajg
July 1, 2011
You should do a post of our need to collect things, and all the crap we’ve collected.
Laura
July 1, 2011
There should probably be a coin commemorating coin-flipping. Oh, and how about a series of coins in honor of famous numbers, like a nickel with a big “25” on its face, a quarter with a giant “10”, and so on?
Carl D'Agostino
July 1, 2011
They should make coin empty treasury/bank building – reality coming soon. And empty pocket citizens too.
Spectra
July 1, 2011
I did do a post devoted to our collections, and it was my most popular post to date! I have to think my burnt match collection had something to do with that…
Penny
July 1, 2011
Great post “Greatsby” – I had to laugh at:….. collect other items like stamps, baseball cards, or husbands! I think Eliz Tayor had the right idea! either love them or leave them. It is a souce of variety !!
Penny
July 1, 2011
ooops !! met Eliz Taylor – she was an interesting lady!
Woman
July 1, 2011
Welcome to Canada!!! Last I heard? They were planning on removing the five dollar bill from circulation and replacing it with a coin.
Interesting post! But if I am honest… you can have all my coins. I’ll take the bills! Weighs less when I move!
Binky
July 1, 2011
Wombats on dollar coins. Solves everything. You could even call them Wombies.
Renée A. Schuls-Jacobson
July 1, 2011
I’d like to see the Fed start doing a series on Barbara Millicent Roberts. That’s right, I want Commemorative Barbies and Barbie Friends. Barbie and Ken (obviously) and Skipper, Tutti, Todd, Francie, Jazzie, Stacie, Kelly, Chrissy and Chelsea. Definitely need Jewel Secrets Whitney and Cara (an African American Barbie). There are zillions of ’em. Highly collectable, especially if you let the busts go down, well… to the busts.
Renée A. Schuls-Jacobson
July 1, 2011
What the deuce? Where did my icon go? Feel free to delete this remark. I’m just surprised.
The Good Greatsby
July 1, 2011
I had to approve your comments for some reason. I’ve been having problems with comments I leave on other sites as well.
Kim
July 1, 2011
I just want a cents sign money bag… That might discourage the muggings
belleofthecarnival
July 1, 2011
Oh! Wait! But I do have a dollar and a two dollar coin in my pocket! A loonie and a toonie to keep my Starbucks habit afloat 🙂
Thomas Stazyk
July 1, 2011
When I lived in the US my attitude toward dollar bills vs. coins was “if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.” Here in NZ we have a one dollar and a two dollar coin and the smallest bill is a 5 and I find I much prefer the coins to the bills for some reason.