
I just finished a month performing a one-man standup show in Scotland as part of the Edinburgh Fringe Festival, and after a month of traveling I feel especially qualified to comment on this survey by Expedia asking 1,000 Americans to name the behaviors they find most aggravating in fellow hotel guests.
29% complained about the ‘Loudly Amorous’, i.e., those who were having sex too vocally in the next room, and 59% complained of ‘In-room Revelers’. It’s worth pointing out that 59% dislike general loud noise, but roughly half of that 59% don’t mind the loud noise if it turns out to be sex. I wonder which half of the population that might be. The degree of congeniality towards the loudly amorous probably depends on the hotel’s cable TV selection. I’d choose ESPN over listening to the loudly amorous, but there are lots of C cable TV shows that transform into a B when you add a ‘loudly amorous’ soundtrack. Hollywood, take note.
It’s worth considering why the ‘loudly amorous’ affects us differently than neighborly noise in general. Here’s the difference between people arguing next door and having sex next door: When you hear an argument you never think, ‘I sure wish that were me.’ Loud sex is a reminder that you’re not having any. Or perhaps you are having sex, but wonder why your performance isn’t producing that degree of enthusiasm.
(Just to be clear, the word ‘amorous’ doesn’t have to mean sexual desire but is ‘indicative of love or romance’, and perhaps some of these complainers were subjected to the loud recitation of bad poetry.)
69% of respondents complained of ‘Hallway Hellraisers’. There are people in life you can never please. 29 percent called the front desk when you were having loud sex in your room, but over twice as many complained once you politely moved the loud sex to the hallway.

Inattentive parent reading an article on parenting.
72% complained of ‘Inattentive Parents’, but come on people, when you complain of the loudly amorous in the room and then in the hallway, it’s very difficult to keep an eye on the kids from the stairwell. And those parents in the stairwell aren’t disturbing anyone unless the unattended kids start a fire and the hotel evacuates via the stairwell.
9% complained about the ‘Elevator Chatterbox’, and I’ll admit I’ve been guilty of being overly chatty on the ride upstairs, but excuse me if I assumed you’d want to hear the latest gossip about that couple in the stairwell.
53% complained about ‘Complainers’. No word on whether those 53% grasped the irony of their position.
Of course this study isn’t scientific. These are complaints from one guest about the other guests but it’s not clear that the other guests are people the survey-taker doesn’t know. If your spouse is also a guest at the hotel a complaint about a loudly amorous guest or an inattentive parent may not mean the person next door.
gerknoop
September 20, 2016
I often put in complaints about my loud kids and inattentive husband now that we are hosts of an air BnB….I can’t seem to get through to the front desk though….
The Good Greatsby
September 20, 2016
That’s hilarious. Have you considered leaving a negative review on air BNB? It’s fun to imagine your husband and kids reading those comments.
susielindau
September 20, 2016
Don’t ever stay at the Stanley Hotel in Estes. Not only does it have your run of the mill type of annoying guests, it has the very noisy ghostly kind as well!
The Good Greatsby
September 20, 2016
I know the common theme in these complaints is ‘noise’, but if I had to have a ghost I would actually prefer him to be noisy. I’d like to know when he’s coming around the corner.
susielindau
September 20, 2016
When I experienced them they were loud and clear!!!
Jackie Cangro
September 20, 2016
“Loudly amorous ghosts” would be an interesting survey option.
The Good Greatsby
September 20, 2016
We shouldn’t be surprised that ghosts have interests outside haunting. Eternity is an awful long dry spell to go without any amorous activities.
Kate Crimmins
September 20, 2016
There are different noises. For a time I lived a block off an all women’s college. I described the noise as happy noise even the time a guy was serenading his sweetheart at the top of his lungs at 3 a.m. That same house was a block from a park. Mostly that was happy noise but the salsa music at 6 a.m. was totally unwelcomed and required a call to the police. I don’t travel much anymore but I remember the toilet flushing that the room next door did in the very early morning always woke me up. Somewhere on my reservation in fine print there must have been a note that said “book me next to a geriatric bladder.”
The Good Greatsby
September 20, 2016
‘Happy noise’ is a nice way of putting it. I like to hear my neighbors and the ambient noise of people bustling out on the street. I don’t even mind some music if it matches my taste in music.
becomingcliche
September 20, 2016
I rarely travel, and usually it’s for a school conference, and my roommate is invariably the kindergarten teacher (who is also the pastor’s wife). The last time we stayed at a hotel, the people next door were rather raucous for a long period of time. The pastor’s wife, sweet innocent that she is, commented that “his lady friend seemed to be really enjoying herself.” I might have died. So really, I’m not opposed to loud sex. I am opposed to the duration. Was that one of the options?
The Good Greatsby
September 20, 2016
Yes, I think the respondents were allowed to rate their preference based on duration as well as whether they preferred more or less volume from her versus him.
becomingcliche
September 20, 2016
I think that’s important. I want to know if I am traveling in close proximity to men who are considerate of their partners.
The Laughing Duck
September 20, 2016
I work in a hotel.. gotta say that’s the best part of job. Explains so much of the shabby psyche of our deprived male management.
The Good Greatsby
September 20, 2016
I do wonder if those complaints are the ones male staff are most likely to volunteer to check out.
The Laughing Duck
September 20, 2016
I will think of this comment each time one volunteers, ” I can help with that “
The Good Greatsby
September 20, 2016
Maybe you should combine other to-do tasks with a ‘loudly amorous’ complaint. ‘Any volunteers to check out the leak on floor 5 while also checking out the ‘loudly amorous’ complaint on floor 6?’
The Laughing Duck
September 20, 2016
Ha ! Good one. I can’t say how many of these little occurrences happen in this supposedly reputable hotel.
Yahooey
September 20, 2016
I think the 29% are worried they will meet the couple at breakfast and feel embarrassed because they were involuntarily included in an intimate moment.
I would have to suppress a grin.
The Good Greatsby
September 20, 2016
It might actually be fun to scan the breakfast tables the next morning to try and match faces to the ‘loudly amorous’. It would be hard not to build a mental expectation of what they might look like.
She's a Maineiac
September 20, 2016
Some people have all the luck. I wish I could be next to the room where someone is loudly reciting bad poetry. I always get the room right next to the ten kids hyped up on candy bars who open and close the door about 100 times an hour so they can race up and down the hall like a herd of elephants.
The Good Greatsby
September 20, 2016
You’ve got to plan ahead when booking. A lot of hotel search aggregators will let you specify proximity to ‘amorous couples’ or distance from ‘inattentive parents’.
She's a Maineiac
September 20, 2016
I forgot to ask–how did the standup go? Any hecklers?
The Good Greatsby
September 20, 2016
It went very well. I was doing a midnight show to an audience who’d been drinking all day so there was a lot of chatting and interruptions but not necessarily heckling. Nobody was negative. They were enjoying the show and seemed to forget I wasn’t on TV and could hear them talking to me.
She's a Maineiac
September 20, 2016
You must have nerves of steel! Kudos to you.
So they were drinking all day? And watching stand-up? What in the hell IS this place you speak of??? Not a bad way to spend a day. Are you making this up just like that cat cafe and Massachusetts/Maine thing?
The Good Greatsby
September 20, 2016
It’s the world’s biggest arts festival held for four weeks every August. It’s theatre, comedy, books, music and visual art. Thousands of shows. Most shows are about an hour and people may see 5-6 shows in a day, eating and drinking between each one so they were pretty exhausted by the time they got to me.
She's a Maineiac
September 20, 2016
wow, so cool!
List of X
September 20, 2016
I bet half of those guests whose rooms emanate loudly amorous noises complain that they never ordered that porn flick and certainly didn’t have the volume all the way up while watching it.
The Good Greatsby
September 20, 2016
Phantom porn flick orders used to be a serious problem at hotels. Hotels hired all sorts of programmers to help sort out the software but the glitch inexplicably stopped around the same time hotels started offering free high-speed Wi-Fi.
List of X
September 21, 2016
I think that the real reason why the programmers couldn’t fix the glitch was because they kept getting distracted by porn flicks they had to play to, umm, test their code.
shopgirlanonymous
September 20, 2016
Haha! What a fun read! I must say loud music does not bother me, but noisy sex makers lead me to absolutely cringe.
The Good Greatsby
September 20, 2016
I can tolerate either but not both at once. You’ve got to pick one or the other. I don’t believe in multitasking.
shopgirlanonymous
September 20, 2016
I can never listen to Ed Sheeran’s Thinking Out Loud again after a night in the Renaissance downtown Nashville.
Curmudgeon-at-Large
September 20, 2016
Regarding loudly amorous, may I refer you to Strange Noises in the Dark by the Austin Lounge Lizards:
https://www.bing.com/videos/search?q=strange+noise+in+the+dark+ustin+lounge+lizards&&view=detail&mid=BBDD6868D7535A754488BBDD6868D7535A754488&FORM=VRDGAR
The Good Greatsby
September 20, 2016
That song should serve as a reminder to those complainers that the noise could be much more personal.
dianasschwenk
September 20, 2016
It’s funny. I hardly ever complain. I lay on my side and cover my free ear with a pillow! ❤
Diana xo
The Good Greatsby
September 20, 2016
I’m with you. I guess I belong to that 53% of the population who would only complain about complainers.
zannyro
September 21, 2016
I once thought there was an invisible herd of horses running down the hallway of the hotel at all hours of the night…turned out to be a herd of seven year old girls. They were so fast that every time I opened the door, there was nothing there! I finally decided to wait by the door and to see if I could catch a horse to take home, imagine my disappointment when it was just the offspring of inattentive parents.
The Good Greatsby
September 21, 2016
Yes that does sound disappointing. A herd of invisible horses would have made a much better travel story than a herd of seven-year-old girls.
pegoleg
September 21, 2016
Thank you for this valuable traveler information.
But the inattentive parent in your picture isn’t reading an article – he’s watching porn to bone up on his technique for that night’s performance in the stairwell. (yes, I went there.)
The Good Greatsby
September 21, 2016
It’s very possible. I didn’t mean to imply there was only one way to be an inattentive parent. Indeed, I’m constantly discovering new methods and might even be considered an innovator in this field.
Go Jules Go
September 21, 2016
I wonder if they included my biggest complaint on their survey: The fact that hotels seem to think a box of Russell Stover chocolates and 5% off of their restaurant is reason enough to pay an extra $200 for their “amorous evening guaranteed” Fall Foliage Getaway Package.
The Good Greatsby
September 21, 2016
I’m pretty skeptical that a fall foilage amorous evening could be guaranteed. Studies have shown a certain percentage of couples do indeed find fall foilage to inspire romantic sentiments, but an equal number view fall as a symbolic melancholy reminder of aging and our impending deaths. With that in mind, I’d pay perhaps $100 for an ‘amorous evening 50/50’ Fall Foiliage Getaway Package.
Lorna's Voice
September 21, 2016
Okay, okay. I got it. I’ll try to keep the volume down on my hotel sex in the room, hallway and stairwell, but don’t take away the random conference room or behind those insanely large potted plants. A girl’s gotta have options. 😉
The Good Greatsby
September 21, 2016
I don’t think anybody is going to complain about the conference room. I’ve been to enough stuffy workshops and lectures in hotel conference rooms to know the audience wouldn’t complain about having a second entertainment option.
Lorna's Voice
September 30, 2016
😉
T E Stazyk
September 21, 2016
Do yoiu think that people complaining about the loudly amorous are just jealous that they are making it last long enough for the sounds to become irritating?
PS–Did you try haggis in Scotland??
The Good Greatsby
September 21, 2016
Absolutely. Some sporadic amorous noise is understandable, but prolonged activity is just showing off.
I didn’t try haggis. The last time I was in Edinburgh I was invited to a haggis dinner party and chickened out at the last second.
The Guat
September 22, 2016
That does sound like valuable information, and I almost missed it as you were absent from my feed. So I needed to subscribe again 🙂 thank goodness I didn’t miss your list, but the ones that burn me out are the inebriated people that seem to think everyone enjoys Journey at 2 a.m. I’m good with 80s bands, but not bad Journey karaoke at 2 a.m. unless I’m at a bar myself 🙂
The Good Greatsby
September 23, 2016
Karaoke seems to be the one occasion we’re willing to appreciate the merits of bad music, but it’s risky to allow someone else control over that bad, bad playlist.
Binky
September 22, 2016
I would only complain if the bar fridge wasn’t thoroughly stocked up with chocolates and wine gums. But I guess that’s just me.
The Good Greatsby
September 23, 2016
That means you’re one of the rare guests who doesn’t seem to be aggravated by noise. But that’s what people do. People seem to be so surprised when they venture out into the world and encounter other people.
Mel & Suan
September 22, 2016
Peace and quiet. That’s all I’m asking for…
Vanessa-Jane Chapman
September 24, 2016
Stand-up at Edinburgh Fringe! Why has nobody picked up on your thinly-veiled attempt to seek praise and admiration for that? Well maybe they have, to be honest after reading the first few comments, I skimmed through the rest, so I may have missed some praise. Anyway, I praise you (not in a religious way). I know you do things like that ALL the time, but that doesn’t make it any less impressive. I did stand-up twice, in two London pubs a few years ago. Terrifying. My friend was at Edinburgh Fringe too, she plays Sybil in a Fawlty Towers dinner experience show thingy. I expect she was one of the complainers in the survey. Any videos? Of the stand-up, not of the amorous hotel guests.
The Good Greatsby
September 24, 2016
You have to live outside America to know the Edinburgh Fringe is the biggest arts festival in the world. I got tired of explaining to my family what it was and why they should be excited for me, so I guess that carried over to the blog. I assumed most of my American readership would shrug.
I did see posters for that Fawlty Towers dinner experience. I would have loved to have seen it.
Vanessa-Jane Chapman
September 24, 2016
Well at least I appreciate what a big deal it is!
Elyse
September 24, 2016
The fringe? You lucky, talented dog. Who cares what folks were doing next door?!?!
I was treated to a loudly amorous couple in a hotel in France, where I was staying with my then 11 year old son during a heatwave when all the windows in the hotel were open. They were noisy for record time. Memorable. Everybody in the breakfast room was trying to figure out who it was … Thankfully, my son slept through it.
The Good Greatsby
September 24, 2016
Some people would complain about that loudly amorous couple while others would be deeply grateful to have a distraction from the heat.
Elyse
September 24, 2016
I’m pretty sure they made it hotter.
Mark Petruska
September 24, 2016
…and yet not one single complaint about the miniature bars of soap that stick like glue to the plastic shower stall. Talk about misplaced priorities. Then again, if the loud amorousness is originating from the shower in the first place, I can see how the soap would be easy to overlook.
The Good Greatsby
September 24, 2016
I can imagine Expedia consciously limited criticism to other hotel guests instead of its hotel partners. Otherwise those bars of soap would have been high on the list.
Carl D'Agostino
September 24, 2016
Sheeesh. I thought a comfy pillow was the bomb. Recently I had my first room service at the Hard Rock Casino Hotel in Hollywood , Florida. It was great but cost me about $4,000. The only noise I heard was that of banging my head against the wall. I’ve followed Mark Petruska(above) for a long time. Talented and funny and always leaves a cool comment on my blog.
The Good Greatsby
September 24, 2016
I think we can assume some of those people complaining about amorous guests were actually hearing people banging their heads against the wall because of high room service bills. Perhaps Expedia should add an asterisk to the results.
Carl D'Agostino
November 19, 2016
Then there was that free t-shirt that cost me another $2,000.