
One of my favorite memories of my wife occurred when we were driving back from a weekend vacation in Dresden while living in another part of Germany. We shared the drive together with three German friends, and the friend sitting next to my wife got a phone call from her boyfriend and they conversed for thirty minutes. The discussion covered many personal details of their relationship, and we all exchanged awkward looks. When she hung up, my wife turned to her and dryly asked, “Wrong number?”
But if someone were to overhear my wife and I talking on the phone, the confusion would be understandable; when she calls me and starts the conversation with, “Do you miss me?” I always answer, “Who is this?”
My wife finds that answer funny and more endearing than if I had actually said I did miss her. And that’s why our relationship works so well. We don’t take ourselves too seriously. We laugh a lot, try and be nice, and never say or do anything romantic–ever.
Unromantic Gestures
The closest we come to romance is if we are out with friends at a restaurant or dancing, and a terrible, cheesy romantic song begins playing, and I take my wife’s hands, look her in the eye, and say as sincerely as possible, “Ohhh, this is our song…we both hate.”
My wife and I often sing and play instruments together, but if I ever tried to sincerely serenade her, she would respond by breaking her guitar over my head. I feel the same way.
Sometimes I tell her I wrote a love poem for her, then I start reading aloud an angry social injustice poem like Howl by Allen Ginsberg:
I saw the best minds of my generation destroyed by
madness, starving hysterical naked,
dragging themselves through the negro streets at dawn
looking for an angry fix…
Then I pause and ask, “Wait, have you ever heard of Allen Ginsburg?” She plays along and answers no, and then I quickly reply, “Oh good, well then yes, I wrote this love poem for you,” and I continue.
She’s the One
On our first date, I knew this girl had potential because she was not only funny, but she answered correctly to both of my deal-breakers for a future spouse:
1. I’ve always had a thing for librarians and insisted my future wife must either be a librarian or have played Marian the Librarian in a high school production of The Music Man. My wife fulfills both options.
2. I also insisted my future wife had to have won some sort of beauty contest–not because I’m shallow but because other people are shallow, and I don’t have time to argue with those shallow people about whose wife is better looking. I need some sort of official title like prom queen, and yes my wife has this certification of her good looks. About once a month I ask her to wear her tiara around the house and about once a month she reminds me that she lost her tiara ten years ago and would not wear it anyway.
Recurring Jokes
I won’t share our inside jokes with you because you probably won’t find those funny, but I will share some of our favorite recurring jokes.
- When we hear the kids coming down the stairs or approaching our closed door, we immediately switch conversation and speak loudly about new ideas for punishments, underwear for birthday presents, or whether they would notice if we skipped Christmas. “But I bet they won’t even notice if we don’t have Christmas this year. And if they do notice we’ll just say Christmas was cancelled because of the war. And when they ask what war we’ll say the Zombie War and chide them for not keeping up on the news. And when they say they can’t keep up on the news because we rarely allow them to watch TV or use the Internet we’ll tell them to go to bed.”
- When my wife makes a dish for a party, I pretend not to know who made it, and then I rave and rave about it and ask everybody else, “Did you make this spinach artichoke dip? It’s off the hook!” And they’ll reply, “Your wife made that,” and I always act surprised.
- If you visit our house and ask if we have anything “for” a headache, we will ask, “Do you mean for getting headaches or for getting rid of headaches?” You’ll get a similar answer if you ask if we have anything for gas, for indigestion, or for a heart attack.
- When she finishes talking to one of her friends on the phone, I frequently ask, “Is she having relationship trouble? Does it seem like she and her boyfriend might break up? Did she mention having her eye on anybody else like maybe her best friend’s husband?” Only a super hot, prom queen librarian would find that funny.
Marital Bliss-ters
Our marriage isn’t always perfect. There were a few instances when my wife failed to provide me with her full support:
- I was not impressed with the singers on the first season of American Idol, and I remarked that I could sing as well as most of the contestants, and my wife said, “Maybe.” Her extremely harsh words still sting today.
- I once asked my wife if I were as handsome as Brad Pitt, and she said no. The no didn’t hurt as much as the speed at which it was offered. I’m not sure I had even finished the question before she answered.
“Do you think I’m as handome as Bra–”
“No.”
In my defense, I was not really equating my looks with Brad Pitt as much as saying Brad Pitt was overrated. But in all honesty, I feel I’m just as good looking as Brad Pitt on my very best day and on his very worstday, and also he has been drinking for three straight days and hasn’t slept, or if he has slept he slept on his face, and the part of his face he didn’t sleep on is partially obscured by a mask of Steve Buscemi’s face.
- The biggest rough patch in our marriage probably came when I had her watch Rocky IV with me, and I really built it up and told her I had watched the movie fifteen times. Her comment asking why an 80-minute movie required 60-minutes of music videos caused me to realize the movie was terrible. Thanks for ruining it, honey.
Happy anniversary, honey. Let’s celebrate like we do every year: I’ll hire a singing telegram to show up at the door with flowers and a serenade, and you can slam the door in his face.
amblerangel
May 16, 2011
Does she have a blog?
The Good Greatsby
May 16, 2011
She has a blog where she occasionally posts about library science. I would send you a link, but I think you would be shocked to read all the mean things librarians say about library patrons.
azzahawk
May 16, 2011
Damn it! And I thought she used that headache joke for the first time on me last week… I even chuckled through my headache, thinking she was very quick witted…. Now I feel cheated, and may not ever come by with a headache again!
The Good Greatsby
May 16, 2011
Next time ask her if she has anything for a heart attack.
frigginloon
May 16, 2011
I think I got diabetes reading this. You guys are way too sweet 🙂
The Good Greatsby
May 16, 2011
Really? If anything, I had anticipated readers would get the opposite of whatever is the opposite of getting diabetes.
frigginloon
May 17, 2011
Hell, I’m lucky if my partner and I talk, let alone laughter and sprinkles of contentment 🙂 Blahahahahaa kidding (he may be reading this!!!!)
carldagostino
May 16, 2011
Keep going. You will eventually move Dave Barry into 2nd place in this genre of writing.
The Good Greatsby
May 16, 2011
I would accept 2nd place in a heartbeat.
Spectra
May 16, 2011
A fine selection for ‘romantic poetry’. Only a very hot librarian could fully apreciate the hidden romantic value in Ginsberg’s ‘Howl’. I have found a similarly sexy quality and tone to Sir Isaac Newton’s line in The Motion of Bodies, Vol. 1:
PROPOSITION XX. PROBLEM XII.
“About a given focus,
to describe any given conic,
which shall pass through given points,
and touch right lines,
given by position.”
Poetry. Pure, Plane, geometric poetry…:cry:
The Good Greatsby
May 16, 2011
Sounds like Sir Isaac Newton only had one thing on his mind.
paulbeforeswine
May 16, 2011
Your relationship sounds a lot like the one The Misses and I have: all about being snarky and smart to each other. We DO love each other, unfortunately most of our friends often see us bickering and pestering one another.
If it wasn’t for our thick-skinned women, we’d surely still be single…
The Good Greatsby
May 16, 2011
We certainly like to joke a lot. It makes it very difficult for us to have a serious conversation, but maybe that’s sometimes a good thing.
lifeintheboomerlane
May 16, 2011
A perfect homage to your wife. Re Carl’s comment: Yes, you are nipping at Dave Barry’s heels. But, that said, I see a huge undercurrent of jealousy here, regarding Brad Pitt. Listen, you can’t be Dave Barry AND Brad Pitt. It doesn’t work that way. Except for George Clooney.
The Good Greatsby
May 16, 2011
Renee, don’t make me choose between wit and good looks–I’m not sure what I’d choose.
omawarisan
May 16, 2011
happy anniversary! I hate that they recycle the tiara like that. it just seems like if you’re a queen you should just get a fresh one.
The Good Greatsby
May 16, 2011
I think she should get a new one every year for the rest of her life.
Glynis Sylvia
September 30, 2011
You could BUY her one every year. And in keeping with your style of romantic gestures, do they have tacky dollar store ones where you live? Or a Burger King crown?
Tori Nelson
May 16, 2011
This is the strangest, sweetest love letter I’ve ever read!
The Good Greatsby
May 17, 2011
I accept your superlatives.
jacquelincangro
May 16, 2011
If you can’t be Brad Pitt, at least you can be the poor man’s Brad Pitt. Not a bad gig, I say. (Or the rich man’s Steve Buschemi. Still not a bad gig.) I bet you can parlay this into a new career. Think of all the times you could fill in the gaps.
The Good Greatsby
May 16, 2011
Of course poor man’s Brad Pitt is more flattering, but rich man’s Steve Buscemi is more interesting.
cooper
May 16, 2011
you should have gone with hugh jackman…brad pitt is so over…
The Good Greatsby
May 16, 2011
Yes, Brad Pitt isn’t as handsome as he once was, but he was still the benchmark of handsome when I made this comment.
Gemma Sidney
May 16, 2011
Aww, you crazy cats sound perfect for each other. In a totally anti-fairy tale way. Happy Anniversary.
The best Valentine’s Day gift I ever got was a fax at work. On it was a picture of a rose (at least, that’s what I think that grainy blob was), a quote from Shakespeare, and my name – misspelled. Suffice it to say that the sender is not my current boyfriend.
The Good Greatsby
May 17, 2011
But he sounds perfect for you. Or maybe perfect for a girl who spells her name very similar to yours.
thelifeofjamie
May 16, 2011
Aw- Happy Anniversary! You should celebrate like my husband and I do- by trying to see who can smoke the other one out of the room first by farting as much as possible.
The Good Greatsby
May 17, 2011
Sounds like you two have a magical relationship.
She's a Maineiac
May 17, 2011
I am dying over here! Dying! (seriously, can’t breathe…my husband and I are playing that game right now)
madtante
May 16, 2011
It’s all about getting each others jokes or what’s the point?
The Good Greatsby
May 16, 2011
Exactly. Who wants to spend decades with someone who doesn’t make you laugh?
Amy
May 16, 2011
Happy Anniversary!
I think having a sense of humor is the #1 most important thing in a relationship. My husband and I have been through some crazy stuff, but we manage because, eventually, we can laugh at it and each other.
People would be horrified if they heard our phone conversations which usually involve him telling me he’s going to “give me the pimp hand” and me replying with “pimps have more class than you.”
I’d take Steve Buscemi over Brad Pitt any day. Seriously. I got a weird thing for the guy.
The Good Greatsby
May 16, 2011
I think you’ve mentioned your Steve Buscemi attraction before. Maybe I’ll have to find a different benchmark of odd looks.
Amy
May 17, 2011
No, I agree he looks odd, but I guess I’m just into that. Don’t change your benchmark for me!
Renee Davies
May 16, 2011
Any party guest asking for something to treat gas at an evening party really just needs to go home.
This is such a funny post, and I imagine, the cream of the crop where unromantic gestures are concerned!
The Good Greatsby
May 17, 2011
Don’t ask if I have anything for gas because that’s just going to make you the center of attention for the rest of the night and you might as well go home.
Bellymonster
May 17, 2011
Happy Everaftering!
Love notes are a fine way to perk up a dreary Monday!.Thanks for the glimpse into your heart.
The Good Greatsby
May 17, 2011
I hope in some small way I’ve inspired you to never serenade anybody ever.
limr
May 17, 2011
How paradoxical it is that being unromantic could be the very soul of romance.
The Good Greatsby
May 17, 2011
I certainly think the sum effect of our unromantic gestures could be the same as the effect of romantic gestures for other couples.
ryoko861
May 17, 2011
Whenever I hang up from talking to a friend( the only one I have)on the phone, my husband’s first question right after is “Was she drunk”?
You two sound like you could have your own show on TV.
The Good Greatsby
May 17, 2011
You’re very like to have such a great husband.
Mark Petruska
May 17, 2011
Rocky IV was the one with the Russian guy, right? And the cheesy synth music? And the robot?
In other words, what’s not to love?!
The Good Greatsby
May 17, 2011
How could anyone not love that dancing robot?
Surrey gal
May 17, 2011
Brad is overrated. So are serenades.
The Good Greatsby
May 17, 2011
You must be a very smart person.
savesprinkles1234
May 17, 2011
Cute post! Happy anniversary! 🙂
writerdood
May 17, 2011
That’s a great anniversary post. I can’t even remember that much shit about my wife. Let’s see, how tall is she? I’m not sure. It’s just short of 6 feet. Oh, and she’s brunette, pretty, and fairly skinny. Beyond that, I’d have to start describing her personality… *
The Good Greatsby
May 17, 2011
Sounds like you two lovebirds have an incredible relationship.
REscarcega
May 17, 2011
You sly devil you… Why say it with diamonds when you can say it with words? Well played, Sir. Well played.
The Good Greatsby
May 17, 2011
I’ll grab any opportunity to use free words over expensive diamonds.
girlonthecontrary
May 17, 2011
My college boyfriend once told me ” Spending time with you is better than smoking weed.” So, basically it’s the best compliment ever. Feel free to use it on your wife. You’re welcome.
The Good Greatsby
May 17, 2011
I don’t know your college boyfriend, but I bet he meant every word of that compliment.
gojulesgo
May 17, 2011
Today marks 8 years together with my now-hubby. I forgot. He reminded me with a text this morning: “We’ve been making out for 8 years.” I’m going to have to send him a link to this post to let him know about the duo that’s threatening to steal our Coolest Couple award. You don’t have room for it in your trophy room, anyway. Happy Anniversary, Paul and Hot Librarian!
P.S. – I can call your wife hot, right?
The Good Greatsby
May 17, 2011
I’m happy to have my wife referred to as the Hot Librarian. She did win a beauty contest, so her hotness has been vouched for.
Erica
May 21, 2011
She won the beauty contest before she was a librarian though, right? So what I want to know is, when she has on her librarian glasses and her hair up in her librarian bun, can people still tell she’s hot, or do they only notice that after she flings off the glasses and lets down her hair? They all do that, right? The librarians?
writerwoman61
May 17, 2011
It sounds like you guys are a good match, Paul…Jim and I tease each other a lot, and we’re so much alike that we often say what the other one is thinking…
Happy Anniversary!
Wendy
The Good Greatsby
May 17, 2011
People give you advice on marriage and what to look for in a partner, but it’s very hard to anticipate what kind of people you’ll both be in five or ten or twenty years. Change is inevitable, and I think a good sense of humor is one of the only indications of how someone will handle unexpected challenges and stress in the future.
Sandi Ormsby
May 17, 2011
Ha! The Johnson’s and the Ormsby’s would be best friends (if we lived closer) That’s exactly how my husband and I are…you just reminded me, our anniversary is May 31st and he scheduled himself out of town on business. WTH? That’s okay, every year I have to ask him…did we get married on the 30th or 31st? “Honey…”
Then I have to ask him his bday…is it May 23rd or 24th? (which, of course, he’s away on business!)
We’ll celebrate when he gets home! we didn’t have a song for our wedding day and had to just pick something.
AND the song we hate/detest because it’s annoying and gets stuck in your head
Cher’s “Do you beliEVE in love after love…” argh! In fact, I’ll “cher” it here. (ha, get it!) Here’s to getting it stuck in your head!
Sandi
http://www.ahhsome.wordpress.com
Lake Forest, CA
The Good Greatsby
May 17, 2011
Wait, are you saying you do like this song or you don’t like this song?
She's a Maineiac
May 17, 2011
You guys sound like such a cute couple. I’ve no doubt you’ll last a long time. My husband and I like to say romantic things like, “That’s it! I want a divorce!” usually out of the blue and over something silly like when I leave food in the sink or he leaves the toilet seat up. The fun part is sometimes we can’t tell if the other one means it. My friend and relatives don’t get it but I find it really keeps both of us on our toes. And it works, 13 years together and counting…
The Good Greatsby
May 17, 2011
It works for us and it sounds like it works for you, too. People like to give a lot of advice and rules for a good marriage, but I feel if you marry someone easy-going with a good sense of humor you won’t need most of that advice.
reelingintheyears.wordpress.com
May 17, 2011
If we had ten gabillion kids we’d look like Brad Buscemi, too. He never sleeps. Except on his face in his jet.
The Good Greatsby
May 17, 2011
He has certainly earned all that grey in his beard.
spilledinkguy
May 17, 2011
Happy anniversary, G.G.!
The first rule of a Brad Pitt comparison is don’t ask to be compared to Brad Pitt…
🙂
The Good Greatsby
May 17, 2011
I think the list I read of Brad Pitt comparison rules didn’t mention your number one until the end, and I only skimmed the list. Where were you when I needed you?
Tien
May 17, 2011
I still think you and your wife is the most romantic couple. Am I weird? Happy anniversary to you and your wife Paul 🙂
The Good Greatsby
May 17, 2011
Maybe it does still qualify as romance if our unromantic gestures achieve the same goal as romance.
hannah
May 17, 2011
there is a story i tell about you and your relationship. it goes like this.
i have a couple friend in shanghai. they are the most fabulous couple i have ever known. they read hundreds of books a year! she cooks fabulous food and he makes fabulous cocktails! they don’t take themselves too seriously! they are brilliant conversationalists! they write plays! they have the smartest children alive! during the time i knew them i was jumping from relationship from relationship with women, trying my best to find love without getting herpes. i saw their relationship as an ideal i could never reach. so one day i asked them: what is the secret to your fabulous relationship? what makes it so perfect? what do you have that me and my 70982534 girlfriends of the past never had? paul thought about it for a moment and said: “i’ve never heard adrienne fart.”
i told that story to my parents who have been married for 40 years once during family yoga. my father fell to his yoga mat laughing. he farts a lot. also, he has been known to say that “your mother thinks her farts don’t smell.” my mother didn’t think it was funny at all.
i thank the johnsons everyday for this story.
ajg
May 17, 2011
don’t feel too bad hannah. you were busy saving the gays from an oppressive government and bad style. i’d take the BBC and NPR following me around for my achievements over the pains over over-strained sphincter muscles and bloated tummies from a fart free relationship any day!
The Good Greatsby
May 17, 2011
I don’t know either of you people.
hannah
May 19, 2011
right on, andrew
Laura
May 17, 2011
I love the “wrong number” story. As to the rest of it: this is the sweetest love letter I’ve ever read.
The Good Greatsby
May 17, 2011
We’ve tried saying “wrong number?” in response to many of our friends’ phone conversations, but it will never top that first time.
Lenore Diane
May 17, 2011
You’re such a good husband. Provided a good husband is someone who’s an unromantic, smart asS. But hey, when you look like Brad you can get away with it. Oh wait. You don’t look like Brad. Yikes. Good luck with that.
P.S. May the two of you continue to live happily ever after – sincerely.
The Good Greatsby
May 17, 2011
Some girls dream of meeting a smart ass who looks better than Brad Pitt on his worst day.
Girly
May 17, 2011
I love love love this post!
My sweetie and I aren’t that clever but we do have our stupid recurring jokes that only we think are funny and that bonds us. And we also beat each other senseless in slow motion and he always lets me win.
The Good Greatsby
May 17, 2011
Stupid recurring jokes are the bedrock of a good relationship, or at least that’s what I’ve been told by people who’ve made stupid recurring jokes the bedrock of their relationships.
Good to see you back. Look forward to hearing about the cruise.
pearlsandprose
May 17, 2011
Your wife is witty too! You guys must have a lot of fun. Happy Anniversary. 🙂
I think you’re funnier than Dave Barry.
JButt
May 17, 2011
I lived in Germany.
And I’ve learned nothing defuses a potential argument between my husband and me than a well-timed dance move. The more awkward, the better.
Meet the Buttrams
May 18, 2011
I just realized and had to come back and point out that I used the wrong homophone for “diffuse.” If I correct myself, that still means I’m smart.
The Good Greatsby
May 21, 2011
And using the word homophone makes you seem even smarter.
berettaluvz26
May 18, 2011
A marriage like that is built to last forever. Mostly for entertainment value 🙂
I’m a sarcastic dick most of the time… unfortunately, my husband gets tired of it every now and then and goes to sulk in his mancave. Maybe someday he’ll realize it’s more fun to just play along.
the master
May 18, 2011
Oh, you married types! Trying to convince yourselves that you actually enjoy the shackles of matrimony, that another day gone by without your spouse bludgeoning you equates them caring about you. None of that for me! I’m a lone wolf and I cannot be tamed!
Oh God, someone shoot me.
the master
May 18, 2011
Ahem.
On a more cheerful and tenuously related sidenote, if there isn’t a zombie apocalypse in my lifetime I’m going to be seriously disappointed. All the valuable intelligence from numerous “… of the Dead” movies, and all the combat training courtesy of the Resident Evil games, excluding 4 and 5, all for nought.
Binky
May 18, 2011
I need some chocolate after that. A lot of chocolate. Thanks for ruining my diet.
educlaytion
May 19, 2011
Well played Dice Man. I just called you Dice Man for no discernable reason. Now I just spelled discernable wrong. There I go again. Sounds like you and your wife are a neat-o match. Congrats on the anniversary. Keep on rockin in the free world.
The Good Greatsby
May 21, 2011
I’m not sure where the Dice Man is coming from, but I’ll take it.
monicastangledweb
May 19, 2011
This is the sweetest love letter from a man to his wife, than any I’ve ever read. You ARE a true romantic so accept the mantle for what it is. Totally refreshing in light of the Arnold, Maria and the housekeeper scandal. You rock, Paul! Did you say how many years it’s been?
The Hobbler
September 12, 2011
I asked my husband if I was as pretty as…okay, I’m too embarrased to say who…but he laughed and said “that is like asking me if I’m in as good shape as a body builder”. I think honesty is a sign of lasting love…at least I hope so.
Louise Lopez
October 8, 2011
Hi! I loved this post. Your wife and you sound like you really enjoy each others company. I loved the part about American Idol and you singing. I was laughing.
Thanks for sharing!
Cheers,
Louise
Ellen Nguyen
June 16, 2012
You guys are so sweet! I’m so envious! I’m only 18 but if I ever get married, I would like to have a marriage like what you guys have! You’re very lucky, man!
Kayleigh Tanner
June 17, 2012
I genuinely laughed out loud over this. I can’t even remember the last time I laughed over something on the internet, so congratulations! I think unromantic romance is actually more… romantic. If you get me.
crazywritermsc
June 26, 2012
you two are so cute 🙂
yumnatarian
July 19, 2012
Coolest relationship ever 🙂
Jason Preater
January 19, 2013
Great post. Personally, I think Brad Pitt is starting to look as though someone has been squeezing too hard on the top of his head squashing things out sideways, but he is irresistible tothe girls. Even Carmen has a soft spot for him and you will find that hard to believe looking at my photo.
Amber
January 25, 2013
It irritates me that there were only 99 comments. This makes it 100.
pmahaney
May 24, 2013
Paul having discovered your blog only recently, I have been rummaging through some of your older post, laughing all the way, until now. Nah just kidding, great stuff as usual. Although, I could swear the words in this post were lifted almost verbatim from the card my wife gave me on our anniversary this year. You don’t work for Hallmark, do you?
littleblissbook
August 24, 2013
Haha this post made my heart smile. I’ve always liked quirky un-romantic gestures over sappy, swallowing a sugar cube sweet love. All the best to you and your wife Mr. Good Gatsby.
– Rakhi
Mrs Finkling
November 1, 2013
“the no didn’t hurt as much as the speed at which it was offered” – LAUGHED OUT LOUD, excellent!!
JolynYoung
March 26, 2014
I just discovered your blog and love it! I can appreciate the sarcastic relationship you and your wife have. When we were dating, my husband would ask over the phone, “Have I told you lately how much I love you and how beautiful you are?” I’d giggle and say “No,” and he’d reply “Okay. Remind me before we hang up.”
Looking forward to reading more of your blog!